In this book, Beth Felker Jones sets forth the case for the Protestant Tradition with clarity and grace. If you want a more dogmatic approach, you will need to look elsewhere.
Chapter 1 introduces some of the common themes of Trinitarian Theology as embodied in the Nicene and Calcedonian Creeds, which are affirmed by Protestants, Roman Catholics and Eastern Orthodox alike. This is an essential emphasis, but as subsequent chapters will demonstrate, Roman Catholicism would depart from the good news of the gospel by speaking of salvation as being achieved partly by grace and partly by works. It seems to me that a sharper statement here would have been helpful. Also, it would have been helpful to have had a clear statement of the dangers of nominalism.
The author rightly stresses that the gospel is good news and should be proclaimed as such; she also rightly reminds us that God Himself is good news. One of the strengths of this book is the underlying emphasis on grace, which we will see developed in subsequent chapters.
Chapter 2 begins to introduce us to why the author is a Protestant. The first section of this chapter introduces us to the Protestant view of what it means to be catholic. In this section, the author introduces us to the concept of catholic meaning the universal church, not an institution. This is vital for any good understanding of the good news of what God is doing in His Church worldwide. This view of the Church is in contrast to the Roman Catholic position, which sees the Catholicity of the Church as institutional. We are reminded here that Augustine taught that the Church exists by God’s grace alone.because of that will lead to the praise of the Triune God.
Beth Felker Jonnes then moves on to the theme of being Protestant because Reformed. Here she speaks of being reformed with a lower case r as distinct from those of us who would quite happily use the upper case R. I do not want to make a big problem here, I have good friends who hold to the same position as the author with whom I have shared fellowship for many years. The important thing is to return to the key teachings of the Reformers. What this means for the author will become clear in subsequent chapters.
Chapter 3 is about how Protestantism helps us be Christians. In this chapter, the author honestly admits to the problems the church poses and wrestles with some of these. The author stated quite clearly that the very brokenness of the Church is aided by a Protestant understanding of the Church and its sinfulness.
She then moves on to a section about “Knowing God in a sinful world” It is in this context that we need the Protestant doctrine of Scripture; here we find a God who reveals himself as trustworthy and who wants to be known. Furthermore, Scripture enables us to develop our relationship with God. God reveals himself supremely in Jesus, but even so, Scripture is the primary way of knowing God until the second coming of Jesus. The author then goes on to outline why Scripture is the “norming norm” for Protestants. Scripture, being authored by God through the Holy Spirit, reveals to us the Triune God. This section of the book is very helpful, and it is hard to offer a short account. I would recommend purchasing the book for the richness of this section. The author rightly stresses that Scripture reveals the living God to us.
The next section of this chapter deals with the Protestant Theology of the Church. The author rightly stresses that the unity of the Church is to be found in God’s gracious work in a wide diversity of settings, rather than in institutional claims set forth by Roman Catholic and Eastern Orthodox traditions. She then turns her attention to Augustine of Hippo and the Reformers. Before doing this, she briefly examines the scriptural witness, which reveals how close the Church is to God’s heart. When the author turns to Augustine, she draws on his awareness of divisions in the Church. She then moves on to looking at how Augustine reacted to the Donatist controversy. He was horrified at the way that they broke the unity of the Church, but he also acknowledged god’s grace was at work amongst them. It is this aspect of God’s grace that is important for us as we consider the Church. The Protestant Reformation is the flowering of Augustine’s theology of grace in the church.
Chapter 4 continues the topic of the Church under the Theme of Doing Church. The Reformation teaches us that unity is found in the faithful proclamation of the gospel and the faithful administration of the sacraments, both of which are rooted in the grace of God. Martin Luther, in rejecting the authority of the pope, sees Peter’s confession as the rock on which the church is built. In other words, the rock on which the church is built is the Scriptural teaching about Jesus Christ.
In the next section of this chapter, the author looks at the teaching about the church which was articulated by the English Reformation. here, we find an organic picture of the Church as a tree with many branches. This concept helps us in understanding the church in all of its diversity as it confesses the grace of God. This gives us a better account of the diversity of churches in the majority world as well as the diverse denominations in the West, all of which proclaim the gospel of God’s gracChapter 5 discusses the Difficulties of Protestantism. The first problem the author looks at is Individualism, Fragmentation and Authority. Individualism has steadily gained ground since the Reformation. One important point made here is that we cannot opt for the individual over the communal. We need to be in community. This is true for any understanding of the nature of Christianity; the Church is essential. God works in the church even when it is broken. Schism is closely related to individualism; the author mentions a list of denominations in the USA, which shows the fragmentation of the Church in that country. Similar lists could be made for other nations. The whole area of authority is affected by the fragmentation of the Church. For Protestants, the Scriptures are affirmed as the sole authority in all things. Authority is primarily reflected in who Jesus is; this means that true authority reflects the character of Jesus and cannot be expressed in dominance or control. The next section deals with the subject of Consent and Peace; here, the problem of modernity is discussed in a constructive way.
The next section of this chapter is entitled, Sola Scriptura and all its Messiness. this is an important area of discussion for Protestants who affirm the authority of Scriptureas God’s Word written. When it comes to a choice between trusting Scripture and trustung the Church the author states that she will always choose Scripture. The Scriptures are inspired by the work of the Holy Spirit. The author states that too much protestant theology has sought propositional clarity over personal knowledge of God. This is a vital point. This shows the danger of trying to master the text rather than submitting oneself to the authority of the text.the discussion of the work of Phillip Cary’s work makes me wonder if there is an overlap between his thinking and that of the Pentecostal Theologian, Cheryl Bridges Johns. Her book re-enchanting the Text, seems to be making similar points. For me this whole discussion can be summed up in the words of an old hymn by William Cowper.
1 The Spirit breathes upon the word,
and brings the truth to sight;
precepts and promises afford
a sanctifying light.
2 The hand that gave it still supplies
the gracious light and heat;
God’s truths upon the nations rise:
they rise, but never set.
3 Let everlasting thanks be thine
for such a bright display,
as makes a world of darkness shine
with beams of heavenly day.
4 My soul rejoices to pursue
the steps of One I love,
till glory break upon my view
in brighter worlds above.
Chapter Six deals with the peculiar strengths of Protestantism. The first section discusses the loving home, the historic church. The author correctly highlights that living within our tradition is a good thing. I am very aware of my own protestant identity as one who is directly descended from the French Huguenots, on my maternal grandmother’s side of the family. I have always been glad to dwell within that identity. The author then moves on to the central doctrine of the Protestant Reformation, Justification by Faith Alone. Justification by God’s grace precedes sanctification. This vital point highlights our unity with Christ and that everything else flows from that. God declares us righteous not because of anything we have done but rather because of what he has done in Christ. Part of this story is that God imparts grace for the whole Christian journey and not just the beginning. The author speaks of the need for us to hear the Word of God from outside ourselves; she also emphasises the priesthood of all believers.
Chapter 7 discusses the theme of “Hopes for Christian Unity on diversity”. True unity is centred on the Lamb of God and our worship of him; this does not distract from our diversity. The author speaks of the unity that the sacraments call us to and remind us of. In the global church, we meet a great diversity of churches, each with its own contribution to the body of Christ. In Acts chapter 2, God honours the diversity of the people by communicating with them in their own languages. This is a key to understanding how God himself honours unity in diversity.
Chapter 6 deals with “Scripture Passages for Protestants”. The author starts by stating her purpose for this chapter. The first passage she considers is Ephesians 2:11-22. Here, the author argues in a rather convoluted way that we are all one in Christ and that the wall of division has been demolished in Christ.
The second passage she considers is 2Timothy 3:10-17. The author states that we need to see this passage against its wider context and also that the authority of Scripture operates relationally. Scripture works good works, and good works are key to the authority of Scripture.
The third passage considered is Luke 1:46-55. Mary is seen as an example of faith in God in this passage, which is her response to God’s grace. We can also learn from how Mary interprets Scripture. The author quotes others here, and this whole section deserves further consideration.
This book concludes with a short Epilogue. Here she once again considers the brokeness of the Church, and as she reflects on it, she states that this is why she is Protestant. In her concluding paragraph, she states that this is not pessimism at the end of the day. But rather reflects the reality of the already/not yet light of resurrection.
Concluding Comments. The attentive reader will have noticed that I have not made any comment about Eastern Orthodoxy; that is simply because of my lack of knowledge on that subject. However, I am more critical of Roman Catholicism than she is. I believe that Roman Catholicism obscures the grace of God.
I do not want to distract from the many strengths of this book. I highly recommend this book; it has so many good insights. I believe this book will repay careful reading.